C. Peak velocity models (Sections 3.2 and 3.3)
C. Models fit to peak velocity of each gesture (reported in Sections 3.2 and 3.3)
1. Model structure
lmer (PKVEL ~ Boundary*Vtype*Information +
(DISP +) Ctype +
(1+Boundary*Vtype*Information|Subject),
control=lmerControl(optimizer='optimx', optCtrl=list(method='nlminb')))
* In models factoring in the mutual dependence of PKVEL on DISP (Section 3.3), DISP (marked in red) was included as an additional control predictor.
* Due to a converging issue, by-subject random effect slope for information was removed in the CVCVC-Close1 model without a mutual dependence predictor.
2. Model outputs
* Significant effects are marked in shaded cells.
• CVCV-Close1
• CVCV-Open1
• CVCV-Close2
• CVCV-Open2
• CVCVC-Close1
• CVCVC-Open1
• CVCVC-Close2
• CVCVC-Open2
• CVCVC-Close3
1. Model structure
lmer (PKVEL ~ Boundary*Vtype*Information +
(DISP +) Ctype +
(1+Boundary*Vtype*Information|Subject),
control=lmerControl(optimizer='optimx', optCtrl=list(method='nlminb')))
* In models factoring in the mutual dependence of PKVEL on DISP (Section 3.3), DISP (marked in red) was included as an additional control predictor.
* Due to a converging issue, by-subject random effect slope for information was removed in the CVCVC-Close1 model without a mutual dependence predictor.
2. Model outputs
* Significant effects are marked in shaded cells.
• CVCV-Close1
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.278 | 26.354 | -0.011 | .992 |
Boundary=IP | -6.050 | 7.354 | -0.823 | .411 |
V-pattern=IA | 2.387 | 7.467 | 0.320 | .749 |
Info=new | 8.817 | 3.546 | 2.487 | .013 |
C-type | 39.476 | 2.503 | 15.774 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | -8.034 | 5.351 | -1.501 | .133 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | 2.237 | 5.328 | 0.420 | .675 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -0.236 | 5.534 | -0.043 | .966 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 11.143 | 11.842 | 0.941 | .347 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.129 | 11.221 | -0.011 | .991 |
Boundary=IP | -4.834 | 3.093 | -1.563 | .118 |
V-pattern=IA | -0.811 | 2.897 | -0.280 | .779 |
Info=new | 2.214 | 2.190 | 1.011 | .312 |
DISP (cont.) | 175.409 | 5.720 | 30.663 | <.001 |
C-type | 26.420 | 1.671 | 15.813 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | -9.124 | 3.375 | -2.703 | .007 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | 1.414 | 3.607 | 0.392 | .695 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -1.514 | 3.402 | -0.445 | .656 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 5.333 | 7.039 | 0.758 | .449 |
• CVCV-Open1
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.143 | 16.140 | -0.009 | .993 |
Boundary=IP | 3.258 | 5.849 | 0.557 | .578 |
V-pattern=IA | -86.949 | 12.043 | -7.220 | <.001 |
Info=new | 5.435 | 3.416 | 1.591 | .112 |
C-type | -22.169 | 2.382 | -9.309 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 3.822 | 6.841 | 0.559 | .576 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -5.894 | 4.906 | -1.202 | .230 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -2.258 | 5.357 | -0.422 | .673 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 18.537 | 10.498 | 1.766 | .077 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.031 | 5.454 | -0.006 | .995 |
Boundary=IP | -9.025 | 3.893 | -2.318 | .020 |
V-pattern=IA | -18.380 | 6.455 | -2.847 | .004 |
Info=new | 0.541 | 1.563 | 0.346 | .729 |
DISP (cont.) | 175.604 | 4.977 | 35.280 | <.001 |
C-type | 2.883 | 1.564 | 1.843 | .065 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 7.544 | 3.716 | 2.030 | .042 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -0.562 | 3.123 | -0.180 | .857 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -3.996 | 2.983 | -1.340 | .180 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 3.536 | 6.199 | 0.570 | .568 |
• CVCV-Close2
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.170 | 19.337 | -0.009 | .993 |
Boundary=IP | 7.210 | 7.503 | 0.961 | .337 |
V-pattern=IA | -92.148 | 12.801 | -7.199 | <.001 |
Info=new | 7.595 | 3.926 | 1.934 | .053 |
C-type | -3.016 | 2.699 | -1.117 | .264 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 5.156 | 9.392 | 0.549 | .583 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -9.199 | 5.943 | -1.548 | .122 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 1.751 | 6.257 | 0.280 | .780 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 24.522 | 15.471 | 1.585 | .113 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.069 | 7.179 | -0.010 | .992 |
Boundary=IP | -11.225 | 3.704 | -3.030 | .002 |
V-pattern=IA | -22.538 | 5.833 | -3.864 | <.001 |
Info=new | 2.723 | 1.781 | 1.529 | .126 |
DISP (cont.) | 178.024 | 5.183 | 34.349 | <.001 |
C-type | 13.503 | 1.726 | 7.823 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 7.924 | 5.664 | 1.399 | .162 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -2.794 | 3.693 | -0.757 | .449 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 1.584 | 3.664 | 0.432 | .665 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 8.154 | 8.031 | 1.015 | .310 |
• CVCV-Open2
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.136 | 13.166 | -0.010 | .992 |
Boundary=IP | 30.217 | 9.879 | 3.059 | .002 |
V-pattern=IA | 71.396 | 8.536 | 8.364 | <.001 |
Info=new | 9.062 | 3.511 | 2.581 | .010 |
C-type | -5.522 | 2.760 | -2.001 | .045 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | -6.108 | 7.165 | -0.852 | .394 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -5.912 | 5.646 | -1.047 | .295 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 2.152 | 6.641 | 0.324 | .746 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 2.404 | 11.395 | 0.211 | .833 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.013 | 4.716 | -0.003 | .998 |
Boundary=IP | -42.606 | 6.433 | -6.623 | <.001 |
V-pattern=IA | 20.606 | 6.273 | 3.285 | .001 |
Info=new | 4.030 | 2.234 | 1.804 | .071 |
DISP (cont.) | 150.745 | 5.361 | 28.120 | <.001 |
C-type | -36.531 | 2.199 | -16.616 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 5.827 | 4.926 | 1.183 | .237 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | 2.183 | 3.943 | 0.554 | .580 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -0.906 | 3.942 | -0.230 | .818 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -0.286 | 8.099 | -0.035 | .972 |
• CVCVC-Close1
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.420 | 26.277 | -0.016 | .987 |
Boundary=IP | -3.357 | 5.938 | -0.565 | .572 |
V-pattern=IA | -2.220 | 7.232 | -0.307 | .759 |
Info=new | 11.401 | 2.627 | 4.341 | <.001 |
C-type | 38.681 | 2.627 | 14.724 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 8.289 | 5.855 | 1.416 | .157 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | 1.783 | 5.378 | 0.332 | .740 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 2.280 | 6.325 | 0.360 | .718 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -8.354 | 11.766 | -0.710 | .478 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.170 | 11.502 | -0.015 | .988 |
Boundary=IP | -3.114 | 3.044 | -1.023 | .306 |
V-pattern=IA | -3.305 | 3.804 | -0.869 | .385 |
Info=new | 1.962 | 2.162 | 0.907 | .364 |
DISP (cont.) | 171.501 | 5.840 | 29.365 | <.001 |
C-type | 25.204 | 1.757 | 14.342 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 3.022 | 3.706 | 0.816 | .415 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | 1.053 | 3.551 | 0.296 | .767 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 2.391 | 3.529 | 0.677 | .498 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -0.310 | 7.722 | -0.040 | .968 |
• CVCVC-Open1
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.246 | 17.300 | -0.014 | .989 |
Boundary=IP | 6.735 | 5.879 | 1.146 | .252 |
V-pattern=IA | -91.288 | 12.938 | -7.056 | <.001 |
Info=new | 9.700 | 2.636 | 3.681 | <.001 |
C-type | -19.316 | 2.438 | -7.923 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 9.784 | 7.463 | 1.311 | .190 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | 1.015 | 5.031 | 0.202 | .840 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -4.841 | 5.212 | -0.929 | .353 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -5.459 | 9.985 | -0.547 | .585 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.053 | 6.009 | -0.009 | .993 |
Boundary=IP | -9.387 | 3.967 | -2.366 | .018 |
V-pattern=IA | -22.501 | 6.009 | -3.745 | <.001 |
Info=new | 3.337 | 1.587 | 2.102 | .036 |
DISP (cont.) | 169.889 | 4.709 | 36.074 | <.001 |
C-type | 3.744 | 1.561 | 2.399 | .016 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 9.845 | 5.001 | 1.969 | .049 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | 0.834 | 2.876 | 0.290 | .772 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -3.160 | 3.133 | -1.008 | .313 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -3.477 | 6.103 | -0.570 | .569 |
• CVCVC-Close2
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.297 | 21.255 | -0.014 | .989 |
Boundary=IP | 17.290 | 7.169 | 2.412 | .016 |
V-pattern=IA | -94.713 | 14.747 | -6.423 | <.001 |
Info=new | 8.393 | 3.244 | 2.587 | .010 |
C-type | -1.780 | 2.520 | -0.706 | .480 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 11.426 | 7.819 | 1.461 | .144 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -1.994 | 5.191 | -0.384 | .701 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -5.947 | 6.455 | -0.921 | .357 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 1.104 | 10.225 | 0.108 | .914 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.123 | 8.617 | -0.014 | .989 |
Boundary=IP | -4.761 | 4.101 | -1.161 | .246 |
V-pattern=IA | -26.812 | 6.048 | -4.433 | <.001 |
Info=new | 2.498 | 1.527 | 1.636 | .102 |
DISP (cont.) | 161.441 | 4.751 | 33.983 | <.001 |
C-type | 13.365 | 1.581 | 8.453 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | 8.360 | 4.280 | 1.953 | .051 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -2.246 | 3.182 | -0.706 | .480 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -1.484 | 3.471 | -0.427 | .669 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 2.536 | 6.100 | 0.416 | .678 |
• CVCVC-Open2
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.076 | 12.592 | -0.006 | .995 |
Boundary=IP | 72.533 | 8.241 | 8.802 | <.001 |
V-pattern=IA | 65.624 | 5.251 | 12.498 | <.001 |
Info=new | 8.173 | 3.673 | 2.226 | .026 |
C-type | 2.650 | 2.519 | 1.052 | .293 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | -0.532 | 9.457 | -0.056 | .955 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -5.105 | 5.594 | -0.912 | .362 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 4.259 | 6.164 | 0.691 | .490 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -0.203 | 10.520 | -0.019 | .985 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.040 | 5.935 | -0.007 | .995 |
Boundary=IP | -6.741 | 5.686 | -1.185 | .236 |
V-pattern=IA | 32.181 | 4.574 | 7.036 | <.001 |
Info=new | 5.185 | 2.387 | 2.172 | .030 |
DISP (cont.) | 114.064 | 5.971 | 19.104 | <.001 |
C-type | -18.969 | 2.360 | -8.037 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | -9.037 | 7.538 | -1.199 | .231 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -0.030 | 4.363 | -0.007 | .994 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 2.306 | 4.289 | 0.538 | .591 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -4.745 | 8.775 | -0.541 | .589 |
• CVCVC-Close3
* Without mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.150 | 18.133 | -0.008 | .993 |
Boundary=IP | 110.647 | 16.370 | 6.759 | <.001 |
V-pattern=IA | 72.650 | 5.655 | 12.848 | <.001 |
Info=new | 11.386 | 3.604 | 3.160 | .002 |
C-type | 19.171 | 3.034 | 6.318 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | -51.275 | 11.223 | -4.569 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -21.329 | 6.707 | -3.180 | .001 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 0.610 | 7.805 | 0.078 | .938 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 3.816 | 16.566 | 0.230 | .818 |
* With mutual predictor | Estimate | Std. error | z value | p value |
(Intercept) | -0.117 | 6.800 | -0.017 | .986 |
Boundary=IP | -35.783 | 9.002 | -3.975 | <.001 |
V-pattern=IA | 0.513 | 3.856 | 0.133 | .894 |
Info=new | 2.600 | 2.100 | 1.238 | .216 |
DISP (cont.) | 189.054 | 5.764 | 32.799 | <.001 |
C-type | 7.760 | 1.874 | 4.142 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA | -48.265 | 7.196 | -6.707 | <.001 |
Boundary=IP : Info=new | -5.695 | 4.664 | -1.221 | .222 |
V-pattern=IA : Info=new | 0.492 | 4.624 | 0.106 | .915 |
Boundary=IP : V-pattern=IA : Info=new | -3.379 | 8.250 | -0.410 | .682 |